We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.

6 min read
Test-Driven Development with AI: Writing Tests Before Code (But Backwards)
Master the art of using AI to generate comprehensive test suites from natural language specifications, then having AI implement the code to pass those tests—flipping traditional TDD on its head.

What is AI-assisted test-driven development?

Link to this section

AI-assisted test-driven development is a modern software development workflow that uses artificial intelligence to generate tests from a natural language specification before writing the code to implement the feature. It flips the traditional Test-Driven Development (TDD) cycle on its head. Instead of a developer writing a failing test, an AI writes a whole suite of them based on a product spec, and then the AI (or a developer) writes the code to make that suite pass.

This approach shifts the primary creative task from writing code to writing an exceptionally clear and unambiguous specification of what the code should do. The developer’s role evolves from a pure coder to that of a technical director, guiding the AI to produce the desired outcome.

How does it work?

Link to this section

The process inverts the familiar “Red, Green, Refactor” mantra of TDD. Instead of writing one failing test at a time, the goal is to generate a comprehensive set of failing tests first and then write the code to turn them all green.

Here’s a breakdown of the typical workflow:

  1. Write a detailed specification: The developer writes a clear, unambiguous description of a feature’s behavior in plain language. This could be a simple markdown document, a user story with acceptance criteria, or even a more structured format like Gherkin.
  2. AI generates the test suite: The specification is fed to an AI model, which analyzes the requirements and generates a complete test suite. This includes unit tests, integration tests, and even end-to-end tests covering happy paths, edge cases, and error conditions.
  3. Review and refine the tests: The developer reviews the generated tests for accuracy and completeness. This is a critical human-in-the-loop step to ensure the AI correctly interpreted the specification. At this stage, the entire test suite should fail because no implementation code exists yet.
  4. AI implements the code: With the test suite acting as a guardrail, the AI is now tasked with writing the application code. Its single goal is to make all the tests in the suite pass.
  5. Run tests and iterate: The developer runs the test suite against the AI-generated code. If any tests fail, the AI can be prompted with the error messages to find a fix.
  6. Refactor: Once all tests are passing, the developer (or the AI with specific instructions) can refactor the code for better readability, performance, and maintainability.

This entire process makes the specification the ultimate source of truth, creating a direct, automated path from requirements to tested, working code.

Use cases and applications

Link to this section

This AI-driven approach isn’t a silver bullet, but it excels in specific scenarios where requirements are well-defined and the scope is contained.

  • Rapid Prototyping: Quickly scaffold new features or services based on a product idea to test viability without significant manual coding effort.
  • API Development: Generate a full test suite for API endpoints based on an OpenAPI or other specification document, then have the AI implement the controllers and business logic.
  • Building Microservices: Develop small, single-responsibility services where the inputs and outputs are clearly defined, making it easy to write a comprehensive spec.
  • Utility Functions: Create pure functions or utility libraries (e.g., data transformation, validation logic) that can be easily described and tested in isolation.

These use cases share a common theme: they are all areas where a clear contract or specification can be established upfront, providing the AI with the clarity it needs to succeed.

Common challenges and misconceptions

Link to this section

While powerful, this workflow comes with its own set of challenges and is often misunderstood. It’s crucial to approach it with a realistic perspective.

One common misconception is that the AI does all the work. In reality, the quality of the AI’s output is a direct reflection of the quality of the input specification. A vague or ambiguous spec will lead to incorrect tests and buggy code. The developer’s skill is redirected from writing boilerplate code to crafting precise, machine-readable requirements.

Common challenges include:

  • Ambiguity: AI models can struggle with nuanced or ambiguous language, leading to misinterpretations that result in flawed tests and code.
  • Complexity: For highly complex, novel, or architecturally sensitive business logic, the AI may fail to grasp the full context, requiring significant human intervention.
  • Integration: The workflow requires a well-integrated toolchain to seamlessly move from spec to test generation, code generation, and execution.

Best practices for implementation

Link to this section

To get the most out of an AI-assisted TDD workflow, focus on providing the AI with the best possible guidance.

  • Be explicit and unambiguous: Write your specifications as if you are instructing a junior developer who takes everything literally. Provide concrete examples of inputs and expected outputs.
  • Use structured formats: While plain English works, structured formats like Gherkin (Given/When/Then) can provide more consistent and reliable results for test generation.
  • Focus on the “what,” not the “how”: Your spec should describe the desired behavior and outcomes, not the specific implementation details. Let the AI figure out the “how” based on the tests.
  • Keep the human in the loop: Always review, refine, and approve the tests generated by the AI before proceeding to code generation. You are the architect; the AI is the builder.

By following these practices, you can leverage AI to accelerate development while maintaining high standards of quality and correctness.

How Kinde helps

Link to this section

Developing features rapidly with AI is powerful, but deploying them safely is just as important. This is where a modern authentication and user management platform like Kinde becomes essential. New features built with AI-assisted TDD are often experimental or intended for a specific audience.

You can use Kinde’s feature flags to wrap your newly generated code, allowing you to deploy it to production without making it visible to all users. This enables you to:

  • Test in production: Safely test the AI-generated feature with a small group of internal users or beta testers.
  • Perform controlled rollouts: Gradually release the feature to your user base, monitoring its performance and impact.
  • Enable A/B testing: Deploy multiple AI-generated variations of a feature and use flags to see which one performs better.

Additionally, many new features are tied to user permissions. With Kinde’s roles and permissions, you can ensure that only authorized users can access the new functionality. For example, a feature generated from a spec for an “admin dashboard” can be tied to the admin role in Kinde, ensuring it remains secure and accessible only to the right people.

Kinde doc references

Link to this section

Get started now

Boost security, drive conversion and save money — in just a few minutes.